If you want to find the geodesic, usually this form of writing the equation is the easiest. The geodesics on the plane r2 are just the straight lines, travelled at constant speed. We can and this is the most common technique derive the geodesic equation via the action principle. The purpose of this letter is to call attention to the problems that such attempts raise, namely the requirement of a more elaborate structure in order to formulate. Part ib variational principles based on lectures by p. Stochastic approaches to deterministic fluid dynamics. The world line of a free test particle between two.
Deriving geodesic equation using variational principle page. Rn is said to be a cone with vertex at x if for any y. An alternative variational principle for geodesics of a. For a spherical earth, it is a segment of a great circle. The shortest length of all the geodesics connecting. So here, i present a well known method of calculating the geodesic equation just from a knowledge of the lagrangian, and then simply reading off the christoffel. The terms geodesic and geodetic come from geodesy, the science of measuring the size and shape of earth, while many of the underlying principles can be applied to any ellipsoidal geometry. For example, they provide accurate predictions of the anomalous precession of the planets in the solar system, and of the deflection of light by gravity.
With the help of these coordinates the motion of a particle and also the path followed by the particle can be discussed. Variational principle approach to general relativity. Pdf geodesics or autoparallels from a variational principle. Finding of the differential equations of the null geodesic, corresponding to. Townsend notes taken by dexter chua easter 2015 these notes are not endorsed by the lecturers, and i have modi ed them often signi cantly after lectures. We will derive eulers equation and then show how it is used for some common examples. We have already shown how to derive the geodesic equation directly from the equivalence principle in in our article geodesic equation and christoffel symbols. An approximation is determined by restricting to a trial space of functions that are nite dimensional with respect to the transverse variable. Since there is no unique way of relating proper time on one geodesic to proper. In the original sense, a geodesic was the shortest route between two points on the earths surface.
Note that we can also write this equation as d 0 or 0. Solution of the threedimensional equation can be characterized by variational principles or weak formulations. Next we prove that this equation for n 4 has formal double periodic solutions as a series in a small parameter. Application of lagrange mechanics for analysis of the lightlike.
A straight line which lies on a surface is automatically a geodesic. The term geodesic comes from geodesy, the science of measuring the size and shape of earth. This is an alternative to the approach presented in the. Browse other questions tagged lagrangianformalism differentialgeometry variational principle action geodesics or ask your own question. The term has been generalized to include measurements in much more general mathematical spaces. The aim of this chapter is to give a glimpse of the main principle of the calculus of variations which, in its most basic problem, concerns minimizing certain types of linear functions on the space of continuously differentiable curves in \\mathbbrn\ with fixed beginning point and end point. Physics stack exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. Physics 3550, fall 2012 variational principles and. The authors have made great efforts to explain and motivate everything.
The equation of a timelike geodesic curve is deduced from a. Schwarzschild geodesics have been pivotal in the validation of einsteins theory of general relativity. Here we derive the geodesic equation using the variational principle lagranges equations. Variational principles in classical mechanics, second edition. They are nowhere near accurate representations of what was actually lectured, and in particular, all errors are almost surely mine. Because from this principle one can determine the qx, y 2 2 px, y 2 2 ds. Variational principles in classical mechanics download book. A variational principle is proposed for obtaining the jacobi equations in systems admitting a lagrangian description. Schwarzschild solution quick recap to begin, lets recap what we learned from the previous lecture. On the variational principle 327 clearly, the frcchetdifferentiability of f implies that f is gateauxdif ferentiable.
The lagrangian is thus, paraphrasing an apt description, the true gene of the motion 12. This paper shows that if a differentiable function f has a finite lower bound although it need not attain it, then, for every. But recently kleinert and collaborators proposed in a series of interesting papers 4, 5, 6 a modi cation of the conventional variational principle in torsionful spaces that leads to autoparallels as the equations of motion for free particles. Ordinary differential equations 11 is the lowest eigenvalue of the variational inequality x. To get rid of the first two terms in the above equation, we go back to the geodesic equation eqn 2. The idea is to consider all paths connected to the two. We have already shown how to derive the geodesic equation directly from the equivalence principle in in our article geodesic equation and christoffel symbols here our aim is to focus on the second definition of the geodesic path of longer proper time to derive the geodesic equation from a. The main body of chapter 2 consists of well known results concerning necessary or su. A variational principle, which is a variant of the classical fermat principle in optics, allows to characterize the null geodesics joining a point with a timelike curve as the.
Thus they describe equivalent variational problems. Christoffel symbols and the geodesic equation the easy. The variational principle states that if a differentiable functional f attains its minimum at some point u. Euler coined the term the calculus of variations in 1756, though it is also called variational calculus. Formal solutions and variational principle in this paper we study quasilinear system of partial differential equations which describes the. Then for we obtain the equation, where is a solution. Christoffel symbols and the geodesic equation the easy way. Consider the case of trying to find a geodesic between two timelikeseparated events.
Variational principles for nonlinear dynamical systems. Its object is to extremize the values of the functional. Mar 06, 2015 derivation of geodesic deviation equation. An example is the famous problem of the brachistochrone. We have seen that coordinates are the tools in the hands of a mathematician. In general, this is the way to proceed, but if the problem has some symmetry to it, then a variational approach is easier see chapter 6. Then it is clear that if the metric does not depend on we obtain the equation, hus. In order to find the geodesic equation, we use the variational principle which states that freely falling test particles follow a path between two.
Remarkably the equation for the case of degree four has variational meaning. A variational principle for the navierstokes equation. Consider for example the schwarzschild metric, given by. Tensors, differential forms, and variational principles. We use this fact in order to prove that in the case of integrals of degree three and four the system is in fact equivalent to a single remarkable equation of order 3 and 4 respectively. The eulerlagrange equation in this case is known as the geodesic equation. Variational principle approach to general relativity chakkrit kaeonikhom submitted in partial ful. This includes lagrangians, vector field theory, metric field theory, and einsteins equations. A smooth curve on a surface is a geodesic if and only if its acceleration vector is normal to the surface. We will exploit the following variational principle to characterize motion in general relativity. But unlike in general relativity, since contorsion is a tensor, it can be added freely to the autoparallel equation in order to generate other covari ant equations. The great mathematicians of classical times were very interested in variational problems. Geodesic equation in spherical surface r santosh kumar1. If you like this content, you can help maintaining this website with a small tip on my tipeee page.
Every geodesic on a surface is travelled at constant speed. This is one of the most fundamental and beautiful principles in applied mathematics. Then this will have an extremum at t 0 so g0 v0 0 for all vand so rfav 0 for all vso rfa 0. The variational principle and the corresponding differential equation for geodesic circles in two dimensional pseudoriemannian space are being discovered. Chapters 6 and 7 the lagrangian formulation of mechanics motivation some 100 years after newton devised classical mechanics lagrange gave a di erent, considerably more general way to view dynamics. Motivated from arnolds variational characterization of the euler equation in terms of geodesic families of diffeomorphisms, a variational principle for the motion of incompressible viscous fluids is presented. Find the differential equation of the geodesic on the surface of an. The aim of this chapter is to give a glimpse of the main principle of the calculus of variations which. Worked example geodesics on the surface of a sphere. Geodesics or autoparallels from a variational principle. Having rejected the canonical interpretation of the geodesic principle as providing a fundamental law of motion or dynamical equation, i brie y conclude with an alternative proposal that the geodesic principle be instead interpreted as a universality thesis analogous to the use of the term. Variational principles and lagrangian mechanics physics 3550, fall 2012 variational principles and lagrangian mechanics relevant sections in text.
In this framework the modes of variation are represented as. The variational method provide a lower bound for an integral functional. Two fundamental examples of such variational principles are due to fermat and hamilton. Fermats principle consider a light ray passing through a medium of variable refractive index r. To do that, it is convenient to transform the second order equation to a system of two rst order equations by. The goal of this book is to introduce the reader to the intellectual beauty, and philosophical implications, of the fact that nature obeys variational principles that underlie the lagrangian and hamiltonian analytical formulations of classical mechanics. So, the variational principle says that timelike geodesics maximizes length among all curves in spacetime nearby the geodesic. Now i should mention just largely for the sake of your knowing whats going on, if you ever look at some other general relativity books, this is not the formula that the geodesic equation is usually written in. Calculus of variations and the geodesic equation springerlink. Meghan sarkis published by university of rochester river campus libraries university of. Variational principles in classical mechanics second edition douglas cline university of rochester 24 november 2018. The geodesics on a round sphere are the great circles. A volume preserving diffusion process with drift velocity field subject to the navierstokes equation is shown to extremize the energy. Notice that both sides of this last equation vanish when the mu index is set to zero.
Here is an important case, where the converse is true. The same ideas lead to useful approximation techniques in electromagnetism, allowing you to obtain highaccuracy solutions to problems for which. It is straightforward to derive this form of the geodesic equation of motion from the form which uses proper time as a parameter using the chain rule. The answer is part of an upsidedown cycloid, where a cycloid. Variational principles in mathematical physics 1 1 variational principles 2 1. This method is compared with the fermats and geodesics principles. The variational principle gives simultaneously the lagrange equations of motion and the jacobi variational equations for the system. If t 0 is a local maximum of g v then ais a local maximum of. Analysis variational principles and global analysis. Then integrate the variation with respect to time and make it to 0, which can be summarized by hamiltons principle.
Principal geodesic analysis is the generalization of principal component analysis to manifolds. Derivation of geodesic deviation equation mini physics. Navierstokes equation is obtained via a variational principle. The smoothly varying inner product captures the idea of curved space. We also discuss a more general way to nd killing vector elds, and some of their properties as a lie algebra. Geodesic equation from the principle of least action.
Recently it has been argued that autoparallels should be the correct description of free particle motion in spaces with torsion, and that such trajectories can be derived from variational principles if these are suitably adapted. In this chapter we will look at a very powerful general approach to. Variational principles in mathematical physics, geometry. This formulation of the geodesic equation of motion can be useful for computer calculations and to compare general relativity with newtonian gravity. Here our aim is to focus on the second definition of the geodesic path of longer proper time 1 to derive the geodesic equation from a variationnal approach, using the principle of. To use variational principle for einsteins field equation and for israel junction.
These geodesic curves, unlike the straight lines of. Again, the point is not to be able to understand the details with extreme rigor, but to grasp the. Equation 1 is called the variational equation for along the solution in the literature a weaker form of this theorem is more often quoted where instead of frechet differentiability a weaker sense of differentiability is used. Calculating the christoffel symbols, and then the geodesic equation can be a really tough and time consuming job, especially when the metrics begin to get more and more complicated. There were a lot of abstract concepts and sophisticated mathematics displayed, so now would be a good time to summarize the main ideas. Chapter 8 33 pages is titled invariant variational principles and physical field theories. It is because variational principles have constantly produced more and more profound physical results, many of which underlie contemporary theoretical physics. Feb 10, 2016 deriving geodesic equation using variational principle thread starter dwellexity. Mar 04, 2011 the geodesic equation is given by, where. Solving the geodesic equation university of rochester. The results derived from our variational principle have some bearings. The fascinating principle in calculus of variation paves the way to find the curve of extreme distance between two points. Thus in calculus of variation we consider the motion of a particle or system.
443 123 1379 17 565 32 379 954 1314 112 594 1368 1439 1202 603 1129 769 730 1480 1419 1540 346 870 231 1087 747 854 361 483 754 548 1195 1551 46 1003 1540 1104 1027 959 145 683 1313 1037 296 123 77